The Difficulty in the Simplicity

Since publishing How We Are Here, I have been approached by readers who understand individual parts of the book but are less certain about what to do with them. Is there a sequence of steps? Is there a practice to follow from beginning to end? And how do the different parts fit together?

Seen individually, many of its elements are not new. Human beings have been observing thought, meditating, turning attention towards the body, practising surrender and questioning what they believe for a very long time. So what holds all of this together?

The essence of How We Are Here can be expressed in one remarkably simple sentence:

Stop before interpretation, and be okay with it.

That sounds simple, but it isn't.

Let's have a closer look.

Stop before interpretation

This is the movement explored in Part Two of How We Are Here, The Opening.

We interpret almost everything. Something happens and thought immediately begins naming it, comparing it with something that happened before, judging it, explaining it, or deciding what it means. Most of the time this happens so naturally that we don't even notice the difference between what we are experiencing and what we think about it.

How We Are Here calls what can be sensed before this awareness of life. It is the direct experience of being alive before that experience has been turned into an explanation.

Reaching this is already difficult. Much of humanity's spiritual and contemplative effort can be seen as an attempt to approach it. People meditate for years. They practise yoga, contemplation or prayer. Different religious and philosophical traditions have developed their own ways of approaching what can be experienced when our ordinary identification with thought becomes quieter.

How We Are Here approaches the same opening from different directions. We can begin to recognise thought as thought rather than automatically becoming identified with it. We can notice emotions without immediately turning them into stories. We can return attention to the body. Inner coherence can show us when thought, emotion and the body are pulling in different directions. Not knowing and trust and surrender can loosen the demand to immediately explain or control what is being experienced.

We can isolate a thought and ask who is looking at it. We can, for a moment, put aside everything we know about our history and circumstances and ask who we are right here, right now.

These are not stages in a prescribed sequence. They are different ways of approaching the same opening. The application of the philosophy lies in recognising, in whatever situation we find ourselves, when experience has become interpretation, and in returning our attention to what is actually here.

But this is only the first difficulty.

And be okay with it

This is the movement explored in Part Three of How We Are Here, Life in Awareness.

Once we have experienced something without our usual explanation, another process begins remarkably quickly. We want to know what it was.

Someone experiences an extraordinary sense of unity. Was that God? Someone experiences the disappearance of the usual boundary between themselves and everything around them. Was that nonduality? Someone experiences complete stillness and an unfamiliar clarity. Was that enlightenment?

And very quickly we arrive at some of the oldest and largest questions human beings have asked:

Which interpretation is correct?

Is the Buddhist explanation better than the Christian one?

Is consciousness fundamental or produced by the brain?

There are traditions, philosophies and scientific theories that offer answers to these questions. How We Are Here does something else. It says: We don't know.

The experience came first. The explanation came afterwards. And that explanation does not arise from nowhere.

The mind that interprets the experience has already been shaped by a lifetime. By culture, religion, education, language, previous experiences, beliefs, expectations and fears. What we have learned about ourselves and the world becomes part of the lens through which an experience is understood.

A Christian may experience something profound and recognise God in it. A Buddhist may understand a similar experience through Buddhist concepts. Someone familiar with nonduality may see confirmation of nonduality. A scientist may understand what happened in terms of the brain.

The experience may have come before interpretation, but the interpretation that follows is conditioned by the mind interpreting it. This does not make any of those interpretations wrong. It simply means that they came afterwards.

The moment we begin to explain the experience, something changes. We are no longer simply experiencing. We are now thinking about what we experienced. An almost invisible wall has appeared. On one side is what happened. On the other is our conditioned explanation of what happened.

The interpretation is not the experience.

And this is where the second half of our simple sentence becomes important: Be okay with it.

Can we experience something profound without having to decide what it ultimately means? Can we allow the question to remain open? Can we live with the possibility that we may never know?

This is why not knowing and trust and surrender are so central to How We Are Here. Not knowing is not an instruction to become ignorant. We can investigate, learn, listen to scientists, philosophers, mystics and religious traditions, form opinions and change them again. But where knowledge ends, we do not have to manufacture certainty.

Trust and surrender allow us to remain there without immediately needing to fill the space. This is not surrender to a particular God, philosophy or explanation. It is surrendering the demand that what is here must first be explained before we can be at peace with it.

And then this has to meet ordinary human life. Awareness does not make ordinary life disappear. There is still fear and pain. There are relationships, loss, love, offence, belief, hope, money, addiction, illness, death and the countless situations in which being human becomes difficult.

Being okay with what is does not mean liking all of it. It does not mean becoming passive or accepting circumstances that need to be changed. It means meeting life without first requiring an explanation of life in order to be at peace with being here.

The questions that prompted this article can now be answered directly.

Is there a sequence of steps?
No. The different approaches in How We Are Here are not stages to be completed in a particular order. They are different ways of approaching the same opening.

Is there a practice to follow from beginning to end?
No single one. There are practices throughout the book, but their purpose is not to lead us through a programme. They help us recognise when experience has become interpretation and return our attention to what is actually here.

How do the different parts fit together?
Part Two, The Opening, explores the first movement: stop before interpretation. Part Three, Life in Awareness, explores the second: and be okay with it.

The Difficulty in the Simplicity

The core of How We Are Here really is this simple: Stop before interpretation, and be okay with it.

But there is an enormous amount contained in those few words.

First we have to recognise interpretation while it is happening. We have to discover that there is something before it. We have to loosen, even briefly, an identification with thought that has accompanied us for most of our lives. That alone can take years.

And when the opening appears, we encounter the second difficulty. We have to resist neither thought nor explanation. We simply have to recognise them for what they are. Interpretations.

Religious, spiritual, philosophical and scientific interpretations may all be meaningful ways of understanding what we have experienced, and we are free to explore them.

But How We Are Here does not require us to choose one and call it the final explanation of what we have experienced. It proposes that the experience itself can be enough.

That may be why something so simple can be so difficult to live.

There is no new belief to hold on to. There is no explanation that finally settles the mystery. There is no doctrine waiting on the other side of not knowing.

There is life before it is explained.

And the possibility of being okay with that.